Heat treating uses strictly controlled temperature modulation to enhance certain desirable characteristics in metals, such as performance and durability. There are five unique heat treatments: 

  • Hardening
  • Case hardening (or Carburizing)
  • Normalizing
  • Tempering
  • Annealing

Each of these five processes alters the fundamental crystalline structure of the metal to improve particular properties such as toughness or ductility. 

 

What is Isothermal Hardening?

Isothermal hardening is a heat-treating process intended for applications with medium and high carbon-ferrous metals. The primary purpose of isothermal hardening is in reducing distortion while improving the metal’s strength and toughness. The way this is done is heating the work until the metal becomes austenitized and then being quenched to exact temperatures and left there for specific spans of time. 

Two well-known tempering methods use Isothermal Hardening; Austempering and Martempering. The two processes share many similarities with their main differences being the temperatures they are being quenched to, the times they remain at those temps, and the end result.

 

Overview of Austempering and Martempering

To understand Austempering and Martempering fully, it is necessary to reference the S-curve. In heat treatment, the microstructure of the workpiece is transformed to obtain desired properties. S-curves are important to a metallurgist to understand when different transformations occur in metal and at what temperatures. 

If we heat steel, or cast iron until we cause its constituents to go into solution, then quench to 1200°F and hold at that temperature long enough, we will cause that microstructure to transform into the softest microstructure, pearlite. If we had instead cooled that Austenite to 600°F before holding, we would avoid the pearlite transformation and instead create a much harder microstructure, Bainite. Finally, if we cool that workpiece rapidly and sufficiently formation of both pearlite and bainite are bypassed becoming the hardest structure, martensite.

  • Martempering quenches austenite quickly and efficiently as to avoid the formation of either pearlite or bainite, resulting in the hardest microstructure, martenite.
  • Austempering also cools quickly, but not as low as Martempering, as you only are avoiding the formation of pearlite, and holding a temperature in the quench until the workpiece is completely transformed into bainite.

S-Curves in Austempering and Martempering

Martempering

Cooling curve in relation to the S-curve. Austenitic steel is cooled at a sufficient rate to ovoid the nose of the S-curve, preventing start of pearli-tic or bainitic transformation. It is then held just above the Ms point (start of transformation) to obtain tempera-ture uniformity. When temperature is uniform through-out the steel, it is cooled in air to room temperature. During cooling, martensite forms. Stresses are low.

Austempering

Cooling curve in relation to S-curve. Austenitic steel is cooled at a sufficient rate to avoid tho nose of the S-curve and held just above the Ms point for complete transformation to a bainitic structure while the temperature remains constant, thereby alleviating ther-mal stresses that could cause cracking or distortion. Time-temperature diagrams like this one give heat treat-ers a three-dimensional view of heat treating problems.

Martempering Setup

Complete martempering setup at plant of well-known aircraft manufacturer consists of ( I ) oil quench tank, (2) austenitizing furnace, (3) quenching furnace, and (4) hot water rinse tank. Despite extreme depth of austen-itizing furnace, fifteen and a half feet, temper-ature variation throughout the working area of the bath is less than 10°F. Used for the martempering of long steel aircraft weldments, furnaces consistently treat parts without cracking or decarburization.

The cooling power (or quenching severity) of molten salt is increased by agitation. When salt bath fur-naces are used for martempering and austempering, two processes that will be described in this article, they are equipped with pumps or propellers to create the required turbulence.

In salt baths, heating is even be-cause a uniform temperature is main-tained throughout the molten salt. In other types of heat treating furnaces, uneven distribution of heat causes problems. Some areas of the work heat up more rapidly than other areas, causing distortion.

Salt baths also minimize distortion by preheating the work automatically. As a cold part enters the bath, it be-comes enveloped in a cocoon of frozen salt. Although this cocoon melts in about I minute, it acts as a protective shield until the work has been safely preheated.

Isothermal Treatment. Today, salt baths are used for aluminizing, an-nealing, brazing, carburizing, case hardening, cleaning, descaling, draw-ing, heating of forgings, neutral hardening, nitriding, precipitation harden-ing and tempering.

And there’s still another applica-tion—isothermal treatment, one of in-dustry’s most advanced heat treating techniques. By using the isothermal process in austempering and martern-pering, it’s possible to hold critical dimensions on hardened steel parts.

In order to explain austempering and martempering fully, it’s necessary to make reference to S-curves, Figures 2 and 3. In heat treatment the micro-structure of the workpiece is trans-formed to obtain desired properties. Essentially, an S-curve comprises two curves, one indicating the beginning of transformation, the other the end of transformation. S-curves are impor-tant in determining the rate of cooling required to avoid premature trans-formation, the time required to obtain a desired structure and the tempera-hire at which the structure is actually obtained.

The shape of the S-curve depends on the chemistry of the steel, temper-ature and time, grain size and cooling rate. All these factors affect the dis-placement of the curve and the start of transformation, which is called the Ms point. The general effect of carbon and most alloying elements is to move
the curve to the right, which may permit a milder quench or slower cool-ing rate than is necessary for a low-carbon or nonalloy steel to achieve an equivalent microstructure. It also low-ers the temperature at which certain microstructures such as martensite be-gin to form.

Prior to the introduction of the S-curve in the early 1930’s, the iron-carbon equilibrium diagram was the only tool available for explaining the phenomenon of hardening. It did not show the effects of heating time or cooling rates. Because it includes time as a factor, the S-curve represents a three-dimensional approach to under-standing heat treating problems.

The isothermal process involves heating steel or cast iron metal to cause its constituents to go into solu-tion (austenitizing) , and then quenching it at or above its critical cooling rate so the material reaches the isothermal quench temperature with no undesirable higher tempera-ture transformation properties.

The quench temperature is indicat-ed by the S-curve for the particular steel being treated. For example, when steel is heated to 1500 F or so, carbide in the iron dissolves to form austenite. If the austenite in steel with 0.80 percent carbon (eutectoid steel) is cooled to 1200 F and held at that temperature long enough, it trans-forms entirely to a soft pearlite micro-structure. If however, the cooling rate quickly reduces the austenite to 600 F, pearlite is avoided. Bainite, a much harder microstructure, results. And, if the cooling rate is sufficiently rapid, formation of both pearlite and bainite is bypassed. The microstruc-ture then becomes martensite, the hardest structure that can be pro-duced. When the temperature of the austenite approaches 400 F, marten-site begins to form, reaching 90 per-cent or more at 200 F.

The rate at which a workpiece cools is determined by the quenching tem-perature, degree of agitation and size of the workpiece. Heat is abstracted from the piece by cooling the surface. Quenching severity is a measure of how fast heat is removed.

Many quenchants have been and are being used with varying degrees of success: water, brine solutions, oil, air (in special cases) , sodium hy-droxide solutions and molten salt.

In austempering and martempering, molten salt has proved its worth as a quenchant from several standpoints. Distortion is minimal, permitting parts to be machined before hardening in many instances. Parts are endowed with higher, more uniform hardness, and greater toughness and ductility.

Martempering and Austempering. Both martempering and austempering produce high strength. In martemper-ing, rapid cooling is interrupted just above the martensitic transformation temperature, which varies according to the steel’s composition. The work is held in a constant-temperature bath until this temperature is equalized throughout the piece. Then it is cooled to room temperature and tem-pered in the usual manner. No bainite is allowed to form. Maximum hardness is the final result.

In austempering, the piece is quenched in a fixed-temperature bath and held at this temperature (500 to 750 F, depending on the steel) until the austenite completely transforms to bainite and the hardening transfor-mation is complete. This process in-volves less total time (no additional tempering is needed) and the result-ing bainite structure has a higher level of toughness for a given hardness.

The 5-curve for austempering, Fig-ure 3, reveals the similarities between martempering and austempering. Here too, the steel or cast iron ma-terial must be austenitized and then quenched in a salt bath at a tempera-ture above the Ms point. In austem-pering, the part must be held just above the Ms point at a constant tem-perature until austenite completely transforms to bainite.

Complete martempering setup at plant of well-known aircraft manufacturer consists of (1) oil quench tank, (2) austenitizing furnace, (3) quenching furnace, and (4) hot water rinse tank. Despite extreme depth of austen-itizing furnace, fifteen and a half feet, temper-ature variation throughout the working area of the bath is less than 10°F. Used for the martempering of long steel aircraft weldments, furnaces consistently treat parts without crack-ing or decarburization.

Martempering helicopter rotor spars in the world’s longest martempering installation. SAE-4340 spars, 20′ long and weighing 90 pounds, are austenitized at 1550°F in right hand furnace, quenched at 500°F in furnace on left, and finally drawn at 1050°F (draw furnace not shown). Final hardness is Rc 36, distortion less than 1/4 inch end to end.

Austempering Applications and Materials

Austempered metal is stronger, more ductile, shock resistant, and less prone to distortion. The process is typically used to create durable thin components from carbon steel or ductile iron. Common austempered components include:

  • Agricultural equipment components
  • Automobile transmission gears
  • Construction equipment components
  • Cutting blades
  • Gun parts
  • Clamps
  • Clips; Seatbelts in cars, Industrial Safety

 

Martempering Applications and Materials

Martempered metal achieves the toughest Rockwell rating of any Hardening process.  The process is used to achieve minimum distortion in very large parts for the aircraft industry, and for extremely tough parts. Some typical martempered parts include:

  • Crankshafts
  • Gears
  • Industrial machinery parts
  • Helicopter Props

Common Isothermal hardened materials include:

Carbon Steels, Alloy Steels, and Iron are the most hardened materials using these methods due to the high carbon content that helps facilitate the transformations at different temperatures.

 

The Isothermal Hardening Process

This process hardens carbon steel and other iron alloys with medium-to-high carbon contents by heating the metal to a temperature that disrupts its crystalline structure until it is austenite. 

After the work becomes austenite, the processes of Martempering or Austempering diverge:

Martempering

  • After becoming austenite, the next step is to quench this piece consistently and quickly to prevent the formation of bainite or pearlite. 
  • Once the workpiece has attained a uniform temperature that is right above the start temperature of when Martenite forms, you move onto the final step.
  •  Air cooling to room temperature.

Austempering

  •  After becoming austenite, the next step is to quench this piece to a temperature right above where bainite starts to form.
  • Once the temperature is achieved, the part must be held until transformation of the austenite is completed to bainite.
  • Finally the piece is either air-cooled or water-quenched.

 

Advantages of Isothermal Hardening

Austempering and Martempering offer a wide range of benefits for a variety of industries. The primary advantages include:

  • Enhanced strength. The hardened bainite or martenite crystalline structure created by this treatment makes metals significantly stronger than untreated metals.
  • Shock resistance. Austempered metal exhibits higher levels of shock resistance due to its exceptionally strong crystalline structure and ductility. Where other metals might crack or tear, austempered components can withstand impacts while retaining their shape. 
  • Reduced distortion. Austempered steel exhibits reduced distortion due to the quenching process. This makes it particularly useful for thin components that must retain specific dimensions during and after heat treatment. 

 

Considerations for Austempering or Martempering Metal

With many similarities in the process, and end-result in these two processes, some good questions to ask yourself when trying to determine whether to Martemper vs Austemper are the following:

Maximum Section:

  • Martemping – Carbon Steels under ½”, Alloy Steels up to 6”
  • Austempering – Carbon Steels under 3/8”, Alloy Steels up to 2”

Attainable Hardness:

  • Martempering – Up to Rockwell c65
  • Austempering – Up to Rockwell c35-54

Physical Properties:

  • Martempering – High Strength, Good Toughness
  • Austempering – High Strength, Highest Toughness

Distortion Control:

  • Martempering – Very Good
  • Austempering – Excellent

For example, a carburized gear with a required hardness of Rockwell c61-62, which is beyond the range or austempering, would have to be martempered.  A lawnmower blade that requires a hardness of Rockwell c46-48 would be austempered to give it greater toughness to withstand dents and dings in use than would be attainable with martempering.

 

Isothermal Hardening Solutions & Lines from Ajax Electric

For 60 years, Ajax Electric Co. has been providing industrial heat treatment products – including salt bath, metal, and ceramic pot furnaces – for customers in a broad range of industries. Whether you need comprehensive heat treatment products, repair, maintenance, or simply a consultation with a seasoned expert, Ajax Electric has what you need to make your project a success.

We are pleased to offer an extensive range of heat-treating solutions through our products, including annealing, hardening, martempering, and austempering. Contact us today to see how our products can help with your next heat treatment project.

Data Sheet IQ-10